Indy Fresh is a locally-based catering company serving Indianapolis and the surrounding areas. We specialize in event catering for any occasion.

Catering gets a bad rap. How many times have you had a catered meal that’s just lackluster, both in look and taste? We’ve all been there. And that’s exactly the opposite of what we do.

Indy Fresh Catering brings you meals packed with flavor that have in fact been vetted specifically for traveling long distance to your catered affair. No wilted salads here, my friend!

We aim to be Indianapolis’ most trusted caterer, and think we’ve earned our stripes in that regard. Owner and native Hoosier Toby Nunley opened up our doors in 2013 to meet a growing a demand for an affordable Indianapolis caterer offering high-quality, scratch-made, full-service catering with a variety of menu options. Our sage catering team, including 30-year culinary industry veteran Executive Chef Craig Baker, know that both top-notch food and service are of utmost importance, and so, we deliver you with the stress-free and taste-bud-approved catering experience you deserve, every time.


That’s because it is! Indy Fresh Catering’s food is made from scratch every single day.

As a local Indianapolis-based small business, we are focused on serving the needs of our community. We also work with local distributors and other local businesses to source our food items, including award winning BBQ sauce and Cornerstone Bread Co.’s baked goods.

Who wants to eat the same thing every time? We sure don’t, and neither do you, right? That’s why we’ve expanded our menu selection to offer variety, including Italian, Meat ‘n’ Three, BBQ, Soups and Salads, Breakfast and more. View Menus

We are not a restaurant trying to get in on the catering action. We are caterers, period. All of our menu items have been vetted for catering. We’ve tested them to make sure they hold up during travel in a car and keep looking and tasting great for hours over heat. And we bring you everything you need, from ice to cutlery, so you don’t have to give it a second thought.

Our team has been at this whole catering thing for a while, and has built a great reputation for service, if we do say so ourselves! We totally understand why you need your catering order to be on time, just the way you ordered it and delicious to boot.

In our eyes, there’s no reason why “quality” and “affordable” can’t be the best of friends. Indy Fresh Catering offers our catering customers the best prices in town for a high-caliber of food and service.

While it’s always great when we get it, we don’t need advanced notice to fulfill your catering order. Our incredible Indy Fresh Catering customer service team gets the job done, and can be contacted via phone, email or even text message.


Toby Nunley

Born and bred in Indiana and a graduate of Purdue University, Toby puts the “local” in Indy Fresh Catering. With a knack for creating systems, quality checks and fostering customer relationships, this 12-year veteran of the catering business oversees our business development and sales and strategic planning.

Favorite Menu Item: Fettucine Pasta with Sausage, Peppers and Onions

Craig Baker

 Culinary Consultant

Craig worked his way through college in kitchens at various restaurants in Pennsylvania and along the eastern seaboard. After his college graduation, he followed his passions to Portland, Oregon and into the kitchen of Assaggio, an award-winning authentic Italian restaurant, where he served as chef de cuisine. Over the following twenty years, he has excelled in the industry by winning awards and utilizing his experiences. His first restaurant and bar, Echo, in Portland was ranked one of Portland’s top 50 restaurants. In spring 2006, Craig sold Echo to his business partner and relocated to Indiana.

He has had recognition for his work in culinary competitions, industry publications and in the press. His work has been featured in the “Best of” lists in both Portland and Indianapolis along with regional and national cookbooks.

Craig Baker, continued…

In 2012-2018 he was recognized by Top Chef’s of America, James Beard House, Zagat, Urban Spoons and OpenTable’s Top 100 lists for Family Friendly Meals and Gluten Free restaurants in the country, Top 10 Cocktails, best of Charcuterie, Top Meals, Hot Spots, Top 25 Restaurants 2011-2016 by Indy Monthly and Eater’s best restaurants in Indiana.

In 2013 – 2018 he competed in the World Food Championships placing as high as first and winning other national and regional competitions across the country. One of Craig’s restaurants, The Local was recognized nationally for its mission to support local economies, farms, artisans, and philanthropy. He has appeared on local and national television and radio promoting different charities, events/restaurants, and culinary competitions.

Craig recently sold his shares in Plow and Anchor, The Taco Shop, Bent Rail Brewery, and the Local Eatery and Pub to open a consulting company. He now has opened twenty-eight restaurants and hotels across North America and the Bahamas. His specialization in opening and in project management from inception has enabled him to work with global companies like SBE Entertainment Group, SLS Hotels, Walmart, Clearwater Seafood along with regional chains across the United States.

Indy Fresh Catering